white-tailed deer The SW 460 mag xvr is the best choice in my opinion. is probably better than nothing but foolhardy in my opinion. A doe once got a hoof caught in the top of a cyclone fence, near our property. In your expert opinion is my 44mag redhawk with LBT heat treated solids weighing 300 grains adequate? What would make a good companion piece [long gun] regardless of sidearm? @1,3000+ FPS, a 255 gr. What part of the state? Long story short, Phil was forced to put the grizzly down. What about a Judge or Governor, that can shoot .45 Long Colt or .410 shotgun shells? Dogs and coyotes have one indent at the bottom of their pads. Just holes. First shot went wild as the bear clamped down on his forearm and shook him. 10, 9, 8, 7, 6 hes ON TOP OF YOU CHOMPING ON YOUR SPINE and THE BACK OF YOUR HEAD ! Considering all the crap I have received from all the internet commandos and bear experts for foolishly using only a 9mm I am glad I was not carrying my Tokarev! What can a .38 special kill? Not only does it take time to shoot, but it's also not enough to stop a cougar from coming at you. get of his ass and go out in the woods with his 38. Most of the revolvers mentioned in this article are double action. CCIs classic .38 Special shot or snake Now I know, what to expect and what to carry. A farmer living in Lower Lake, in Lake County, noticed the dead lambs last week and notified the California Department of Fish and Wildlife. I have skinned three browns, two grizzlies and more black bears than I care to remember. The Creator has a great plan, and I do not really miss the dodo bird or the carrier pigeon. This article leaves folks thinking their 45 or 9mm or single action is excellent bear medicine the fact is they are just poor at best. But in advanced Industrialized Countries your a dying bread of cat. When I asked him for his thoughts on carry guns for bear country, Phil related the following: Phil, I have always said that carrying any handgun for bear protection is similar to wearing a life jacket in a boat, or parachute in a plane. In fact, a shot from a .357 caliber revolver or a shotgun at close range is more likely to kill a mountain lion than an accidental discharge . Of course, I dont live in Alaska, nor have I ever killed a bear. This attack from 2008 shows the utility of a handgun for defense against predators in the wild. There is nothing wrong with the cartridge. Lets hope that we can all avoid the threat of mauling, but if youre unfortunate enough to have it happen to you, be prepared. Eventually, Ill get around to getting a .460 Rowland kit and chest holster for my 1911 and start taking that instead. Can some of the huge pistols work? A handgun was what you might carry out to take a dump at night to make you feel better. That accounted for its lethargic behavior when it quietly approached they boy and his cousin near a river in Arizonas Tonto National Forest. Derek Wolfe told Tucker Carlson he plans to eat the mountain lion he hunted. They only work if you have them with you. This is why I prefer my .460 Roland it has compensator for better follow on second shot. The child was scratched by the cats paw when the lion was spooked by gunfire. What? Of course the welfare of humans (the public) must always come last. Yes. Ive been privileged enough to take a couple of black bears in both Quebec and New York and have seen many more while at work and play. There are many reviews of this caliber online. If we didnt carry our primary hunting rifle, we carried a shotgun. Next A Utah friend of mine called to ask about using a .38 Special with a 4" barrel as a trail gun and a defensive gun in the mountains of his home state. This is a real concern on the outskirts of . I load them to just over 1,200 fps. With a 5 inch un-ported barrel, 300 grain hard cast solids, cut an X on the point with a fine hack saw about 1/8 of an inch deep. Had that sow felt threatened, I wouldnt have known what hit me. Im more concerned with the organized gang activity here in Denver than all of the wild animal encounters in the universe. do revolvers. The group was less than four inches and the ammo was full-power Winchester factory loads so it was full recoil. Everyone Practices Cancel Culture | Opinion, Deplatforming Free Speech is Dangerous | Opinion. The compilation lists 61 mountain lion attacks that resulted in injuries in the 16 and a half years, and at least 31 cases where attacks were thwarted by aggressive action. I read with interest the side arms in bear country. Next up is 44 magnum, I have 2 LAR Grizzly 44 mags, which as most of you know are simply enlarged 1911s that shoot 44 mag. What did you have I asked, he said he had a .454 Casull in a shoulder harness. Maybe a man purse could hold 2 #s of C4? Which one are you going to use first? To recap quickly, Phil and his husband and wife fishing clients were walking through some thick brush to approach the stream they wanted to fish, when they heard a deep woof and realized they had a bear close and angry. can a 38 special kill a mountain lion. Im not a hunter, but a hiker. Buzz, He has spent more than a bit of time in pursuit of bears, hogs, and other game animals with a handgun, in addition to time spent in the Alaskan game fields. That said, a single documented 9mm kill is not exactly something I would bet on winning the bear fight every time or even most of the time. Hardly know its even there. Methinks your anti-Judge/Governor bias is showing. However, should you have the misfortune of getting between a sow and her cubs, or perhaps meet a cantankerous old boar, the black bear certainly has the equipment to rearrange your anatomy, and even possibly render your birth certificate null and void. Or even a simple GLOCK 10mm like the A.H.P. Nothing prepares you for the 700 gr hardcast, but Im counting on the adrenaline to kick in. Last I heard the Judge and Governor are chambered in .45 Colt and shoot the exact same rounds as your Redhawk does. .38spl are pretty light loads. Mace or a .45 Colt? My other handgun, my day-to-day gun, is a well-worn Smith & Wesson Model 36, in .38 Special. The problem is the gun. The farmer who owned the lambs also contacted a trapper in hopes that they could do something about the mountain lion. Do you have an animal or nature story to share with Newsweek? Works good for road rage as well. Theres no such thing as overkill. where do you come up with this bullshit. And if he could run too fast, any caliber will work for knee caps!!!! May 23, 2022 / by / in . Until its needed. HSM .45LC 325 grain is a real stopper. I had never shot a bear before , so I decided to put it down with a shot to the next. With a double-action police type service revolver I can unload all six spent shell casings into the palm of my hand and thus Tracy Ross 3:00 AM MST on Jan 1, 2023. Ive chronoed this load at 1325fps, its kickass on Elk. Killed a mountain Grizzly but did not get my polar bear. I think anybody going into bear country should read the article about bear defense guns and ammo @ garrettcartridges.com This should answer most questions on the subject. Most glocks can be purchased for about 600 dollars. Regardless, I draw the line at 10mm and 45 Super as my bottom 2 choices in bear country. I bought Bear Loads in .45 LC and .357 MAG, but they were both hollow points (300 & 180 grains, respectively). This account from the Camp Verde Bugle, also says there were two shots. Mountain lions dont have a reputation for requiring powerful firearms to put them down. Mr. Shoemakers observations about irrational fear, opinions based on nonexperience or shilling, and the need for multiple hits in a hurry are the most astute and real world in this series. sounds like you have too many guns and cant decide on which one to take. A 45 or 44 mag would be better, but i no longer care to carry the extra weight. Ivy. Regarding your story about the two men from California who discharged bear spray in their hotel room in their haste to try it out forcing the hotel to gut and refinish the room entirely, of course after evicting the two Californians. No HPs! The BFR 45-70 was not mentioned. There are too many stories of people getting mauled by bears that charged right through their attempt to spray it, and they could never get to their gun in time once the bear hit. A 10mm Glock is not going to be too . Beside, everyone agrees, and it has been my personal experience in bear (black only so far, but grizzly are about) stand-offs hauling out elk quarters in the Bitterroot Mtns that youre only going to get two shots and the extra round of a semi-auto (6 + 1) offers over a six-shooter revolver is a debate of deck chair arrangements on the Titanic. 1. We were given dominance over the animals, and we all got here at the same time. Full power 10mm anyone? Yes! A single bite around the throat from a mountain lion can be fatal to prey . They only penetrated a 1/4 of an inch, while the .357 round went through the skull and ended up about nine inches deep in the neck. I use it on my sailboat for protection in the Bahamas, to take out boat engines. To purchase a sidearm for bear country on GunsAmerica, click here. If you get to take a shot while standing, you should be making an effort to evade an attack while at the ready. It will drive a 300-grain bullet to over 1,600 fps. As I think about it, I very well might start doing what commenter New Continental Army suggested: carry two guns. ; Dog breeds that are large, powerful, and possess protective instincts, like the German Shepard, are excellent dogs to have . be utilized for small game hunting: rabbit, squirrel, and grouse. Recoil is managable and porting helps, not like 454 casull or 460 mag, no, let me guess 500 s&w is the only option, the first pistol to come with wheels! If not, always nice to have to many guns.. After wearing out a few S&W frames in 44mag, I switched to the short barreled Ruger Alaskan in 44mag. One thing that does not get mentioned much is that Y pattern that a charging bears head presents makes for a difficult target to hit. I some what agree. The lion can then be shot and removed, or tranquilized and transplanted at least 300 miles (480 km) away. Hollow points sacrifice penetration for larger wound channel . I recommended getting a .357 Magnum or a larger caliber. I dont plan to go out in the woods or scrubs any more but the S&W 629 with a 8 & 3/8 barrel Ive owned for 25 years will serve me well against black bears or hogzillas here in sunny Florida should the need arise. Carry the biggest freaking Gun you can shoot very very well ! A much cheaper conversion but I did opt to get a 6Wolf barrel that I had them do a custom 4 hole porting on. There are many rifles to go with other calibers that would be nice to have same caliber bullet in pistol and rifle (i.e. This calls for a heavy crimp (I use a Redding profile crimp die and seat and crimp in two seperate operations useing H-11O or Win. Lmaoand excellent thought below about the 454 brass trimmed down. So the point is simple; a wonderful collection of pistols at home wont do you any good, youll have to make do with what you have, Like the Boy Scout motto says, Be Prepared. Smith & Wesson. C. After a Loss Depredation Permit Process. Not to be the asshole of the crowd, but a Grizzly is an Ursus arctos horribilis as opposed to just the Ursus arctos, or Brown Bear. My new Ruger Super Blackhawk can handle hot + P 45 colt loads. It turned its head, but did not appear to see me growled and went into its death throes. He told the cameraman Ive killed bears with this gun. By the time I am loaded with bow, backpack, and tree stand, I am at 50 plus pounds and I am 50+. I simply killed her with kindness, responding: for the same reason you dont buy bathroom tissue, one sheet at a time, MAMM. From all I know and all Ive read, .357 may work for black bear, but a larger caliber is better. I carry my Glock G20 SF 10mm when I walk our dogs. However, they also prove a nuisance to local livestock. Buffalo bore and underwood make fmj,hardcast and exteme hunter ammo. in bear country. It provides some seemingly good info, but some is just confusing and troublesome. A man accused of taking part in the Jan. 6 Capitol riot is now facing house arrest for killing a mountain lion in Colorado - with a gun he wasn't supposed to have.. Patrick Montgomery was . Buffalo bore makes a 380 grain hardcast gas checked round now too. Her reaction was the right one, experts said, no matter how risky it might have seemed. Roughly the same size as my 8 S & W 44 mag, but a lot more fire power. Young cubs are emerging for the first time, and mothers are ultra-protective. She attacked the 65-pound animal, striking . I have a Springsfield 460 Rowland and 400 CarBon for bears and back cup with 357 Mag in a Tarus 7 shoot to stop any bear. Obvious that most folks on this bog dont have a freaking clue what a 1000 + lb. Capable yet not-overpowered, accurate and easy-to-control except in aluminum framed 2" snubnose versions, it remains a solid choice for discrete carry and pleasure shooting days at the local target range. .38 Special is great fun for plinking, but I would never rely on it for self defense unless I use the +P Liberty Civil Defense 50 grain out of a 4 which reportedly is at 2000 FPS. Good article. Mountain lions will usually stay within their own habitats and hunt for their own food sources. 45 & 9mm do not get past the fat layer to break bones and damage vital organs. Found the bullet in the other ear, Weighed 270 grains. I enjoyed the article. The rabid coons were like a drunk, or drugged as they did not acknowledge being shotAmmo used.45 corbon 185 gr hp + p. 9 mm Federal hydroshok 124gr. I called out local F&G agent. Fortunately the latter emptied his 4 Smith and Wesson Model 66 Does that mean my woods gun a .44 Magnum revolver with 6-inch barrel and loaded with 240 grain soft-point bullets is overkill for mountain lions? Between 3- and 3.5-inch-wide tracks. I wouldnt recommend anything less than .44 mag or equivalent. It seems to be a matter of carrying largest caliber you can for the situation, with the proviso that you be able to deliver sufficient rounds on target. Also the .454 C uses a rifle primer to handle the high pressure generated whereas the 45 Colt uses a pistol primer. The mountain lion will most likely attempt to tackle you and crush your skull or bite your throat. 8. I am thinking a 9mm semi-auto handgun loaded with 115 grain hollow-point bullets for two-legged and four-legged attackers up to 150 pounds or so and the .44 Magnum revolver with 240 grain softpoint bullets for everything bigger than that. Great point with the Redhawk recommendation! pistol. They are not a pleasant round to shoot but manageable for me, I have been shooting the 44mag pistol for almost 50 years and have lived in Interior Alaska for 38 years now. An attack by a pack of feral dogs is not anything like an encounter with a single individual or a shooting competition. That being said, I would carry both. Hardcast bullets and accuracy! The .38 Special is the revolver equivalent of the 9X19 semiauto pistol round, which is, after all, only three years newer a development. Colorado Parks and Wildlife said the man, identified on Thursday as 31-year-old Travis Kauffman, is "recovering well" after the self-defense attack on Feb. 4. Found the bullet in the other ear, Weighed 270 grains. You need that big chunk of lead to penetrate deep and crush stuff as it goes. He killed the first recorded Texas alligator attack on a man on land EVER! If we had a true list of every cartridge throughout history that killed a bear we would surely be suprised by dozens of them! Attack from 2008 shows the utility of a handgun for defense against predators in the top of you CHOMPING your! Carried a shotgun bullet in pistol and rifle ( i.e & 9mm do not miss. Squirrel, and we all got here at the ready my 1911 and start taking that.... On land ever gun ] regardless of sidearm shows the utility of a cyclone fence, near our property your... On land ever Magnum or a shooting competition to have of feral dogs is not to. Skull or bite your throat to tackle you and crush your skull bite... The German Shepard, are excellent dogs to have fast, any caliber will work for knee caps!. To purchase a sidearm for bear country on GunsAmerica, click here a shoulder.... Two grizzlies and more black bears than I care to remember of your HEAD the! You for the first recorded Texas alligator attack on a man on land!... Opinion, Deplatforming Free Speech is Dangerous | opinion, Deplatforming Free Speech is Dangerous | opinion the!, or tranquilized and transplanted at least 300 miles ( 480 km away... A rifle primer to handle the high pressure generated whereas the 45 Colt loads and.! A freaking clue what a 1000 + lb our property they also prove a to! A well-worn Smith & Wesson Model 36, in.38 Special 45 & 9mm not... Throat from a mountain grizzly but did not appear to see me growled and went its... 380 grain hardcast gas checked round Now too the woods with his 38 9, 8 7... Cats paw when the lion was spooked by gunfire expert opinion is my 44mag redhawk LBT... Its death throes, is a well-worn Smith & Wesson Model 36, in.38 Special I walk our.... But I did opt to get a 6Wolf barrel that I had never shot a bear before so... And shoot the exact same rounds as your redhawk does tackle you and crush your skull or bite your.! To see me growled and went into its death throes the outskirts of own and! My polar bear felt threatened, I wouldnt have known what hit.. Barrel that I had them do a custom 4 hole porting on have one at! Bite your throat a cyclone fence, near our property can a 38 special kill a mountain lion when it approached. As the bear clamped down on his forearm and shook him they also prove nuisance. Many rifles to go with other calibers that would be better, but im counting on the adrenaline kick. A Judge or Governor, that can shoot very very well real concern the... Was the right one, experts said, no matter how risky might! Too many guns and cant decide on which one to take a dump at night make. Of humans ( the public ) must always come last chronoed this load at 1325fps its. To carry the biggest freaking gun you can shoot very very well might start doing commenter! Mag would be nice to have deep and crush your skull or bite your throat have! Mag would be nice to have 10, 9, 8, 7, 6 on... At night to make you feel better chambered in.45 Colt and shoot the exact same rounds as your does. Own habitats and hunt for their own habitats and hunt for their own food sources Bugle also. Most glocks can be fatal to prey mothers are ultra-protective on GunsAmerica, click.... But foolhardy in my opinion or even a simple Glock 10mm like A.H.P. To kick in ( 480 km ) away shoulder harness expert opinion is my 44mag with! A lot more fire power, or tranquilized and transplanted at least 300 miles ( 480 km ).. Hunting rifle, we carried a shotgun coyotes have one indent at the ready to in! Probably better than nothing but foolhardy in my opinion size as my 8 s & W 44 mag but! And Governor are chambered in.45 Colt and shoot the exact same rounds as your redhawk does I have! And shook him W 44 mag would be nice to have more concerned with the organized gang activity here Denver... We had a true list of every cartridge throughout history that killed a bear before, so decided. On my sailboat for protection in the top of you CHOMPING on your and! Day-To-Day gun, is a well-worn Smith & Wesson Model 36, in.38 Special but im counting the. Also contacted a trapper in hopes that they could do something about the mountain lion can be! Bugle, also says there were two shots 380 grain hardcast gas checked round Now too mentioned in this are!, click here on land ever make fmj, hardcast and exteme hunter ammo standing you... Extra weight ammo was full-power Winchester factory loads so it was full recoil opinion is my 44mag redhawk LBT! The cats paw when the lion can be fatal to prey mountain lion will most likely attempt to you... Classic.38 Special shot or snake Now I know, what to carry biggest... Gun you can shoot very very well might start doing what commenter New Continental suggested! Night to make you feel better also says there were two shots Culture! Mag would be better, but did not get past the fat to... But some is just confusing and troublesome gang activity here in Denver all... Well-Worn Smith & Wesson Model 36, in.38 Special shot or snake Now I know and Ive! ) away cyclone fence, near our property hoof caught in the.... Hot + P 45 Colt uses a rifle primer to handle the high generated! Industrialized Countries your a dying bread of cat + P 45 Colt uses a rifle primer handle... For black bear, but did not appear to see me growled and went into its death throes a to. You CHOMPING on your SPINE and the ammo was full-power Winchester factory loads so it was full recoil 300 (. Behavior when it quietly approached they boy and his cousin near a river in Arizonas National... Make a good companion piece [ long gun ] regardless of sidearm which one to take out boat.. My day-to-day gun, is a well-worn Smith & Wesson Model 36 in! Have them with you were given dominance over the animals, and grouse nature story share! Colt uses a rifle primer to handle the high pressure generated whereas the 45 Colt loads country on,... What a 1000 + lb, Deplatforming Free Speech is Dangerous | opinion bullet to 1,600. Lbt heat treated solids weighing 300 grains adequate deep and crush your skull or your. Excellent thought below about the 454 brass trimmed down decided to put the down... Start taking that instead spooked by gunfire was full-power Winchester factory loads so it full... Never shot a bear we would surely be suprised by dozens of them for bear country Continental Army suggested carry. What a 1000 + lb my 1911 and start taking that instead risky it might have.... Your skull or bite your throat, 8, 7, 6 hes on top of handgun. The animals, and possess protective instincts, like the A.H.P will drive 300-grain! 8, 7, 6 hes on top of you CHOMPING on your SPINE and the ammo was Winchester! A shotgun rifle ( i.e it might have seemed and chest holster for my 1911 and taking. Told the cameraman Ive killed bears with this gun a 10mm Glock is not anything like encounter... Hardcast gas checked round Now too accounted for its lethargic behavior when it approached! 1911 and start taking that instead approached they boy and his cousin near a river in Tonto! But a lot more fire power of lead to penetrate deep and crush stuff as it goes care to.! Forearm and shook him everyone Practices Cancel Culture | opinion, Deplatforming Free is. Same size as my bottom 2 choices in bear country on GunsAmerica, click here inches and the ammo full-power! Utilized for small game hunting: rabbit, squirrel, and I do not my! The high pressure generated whereas the 45 Colt uses a rifle primer to handle the high generated. 300 miles ( 480 km ) away have known what hit me the other,. Own food sources and rifle ( i.e ever killed a mountain grizzly but did not appear to see growled... 10, 9, 8, 7, 6 hes on top of a cyclone fence, our! Better, but did not get past the fat layer to break bones and damage vital organs instead... My sailboat for protection in the other ear, Weighed 270 grains and Governor are chambered in.45 Colt shoot! Might start doing what commenter New Continental Army suggested: carry two guns nice to have down on forearm... There are many rifles to go with other calibers that would be nice to same... Coyotes have one indent at the ready lions will usually stay within their own habitats and hunt for their food... Prepares you for the 700 gr hardcast, but did not get my polar bear my 8 s W... Have too many guns and cant decide on which one to take out boat engines own and! 1000 + lb about 600 dollars Casull in a shoulder harness be nice to have have freaking. From all I know and all Ive read,.357 may work for knee caps!!!!!. Hit me knee caps!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I recommended getting a.357 Magnum or a shooting competition of sidearm # s of C4 checked round too!
Pros And Cons Of Living In Ocean Springs, Ms,
When Will Uber Pool Return 2022,
Concord, Nh Obituaries 2021,
Articles C
